1989 (Games about the Cold War, #6)

How time flies – it is already the sixth installment of my series on board games about the Cold War (here are parts 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5). Today, we go to the very end of the Cold War – the collapse of Communism in Central and Eastern Europe in 1989: Dawn of Freedom (Ted Torgerson/Jason Matthews, GMT Games). As usual, we’ll look at it in both game and academic terms.

What Kind of Cold War Is This?

1989 pitches the Communist governments of Central and Eastern Europe against the wide variety of protest groups (labelled „Democrat“ in the game). They wrestle for control over cities and socio-economic groups. Eventually, they will face off in power struggles for the future of entire countries. Both sides have their own vulnerabilities: The Communists have to stem the wave of history and may be irreversibly kicked out of one country’s government after another. The Democrats, on the other hand, start in a weak position and their dissent may be snuffed out by state repression before they ever get the chance to grow irresistible.

What’s Noteworthy About the Game?

1989 employs skilful, multifaceted manipulation of time and space. The spaces on the board go beyond mere topography as they represent not only a city, but also a socio-economic group – say, some workers, or the church in a country. The sub-division of the year in a beginning (half the year), a middle (several months), and end (only the last few weeks) represents the acceleration of the struggle. Time and space also interact with one another: The makeup of the event cards for each of the three phases in the game steers the action to the countries which historically were the focal points at the respective times – for example, the dissent begins to spread from Poland and Hungary, early hotbeds of reformist thought.

CatholicPoland.jpg

The Catholic church is the heart of Poland. It couples a very high stability (5) with excellent access to and influence on a plethora of worker spaces, most of them crucial battlegrounds (bluish-reddish hue). Detail of the 1989 map, ©GMT Games.

1989 is one of the few Cold War-themed board games to feature playable non-state agents (as the Democratic player represents the myriads of groups protesting against the Communist regimes). Despite this asymmetrical player setup – Communist states versus Democratic non-state groups – both sides use the same instruments and play by the same rules (certainly helpful for learning the game!). The card events, however, make sure that the two sides feel very different: The Communist player relies on the old elites and the state‘s forces of repression. The Democrat, on the other hand, can draw on the power of a mass movement as well as the support of the students and intellectuals.


I’ve mentioned already that the two players represent a plethora of individual historical agents. The Communist governments ranged from the Hungarian Communists who aspired to be the vanguard of reforms, over the Polish government which let the Democrats slowly shove them aside, to Ceausescu in Romania who was ready to massacre his own people to keep power. The myriad of anti-Communist protester groups were even more different, from mass movements like Solidarność to tiny circles of only a few people and espousing views as diverse as reform socialism, traditional Catholicism, the concern for the environment in their home town, or just the wish to finally own a TV and a car like the relatives in the West. 1989 represents all these different groups and ways of thinking – many of which are now forgotten by most people who did not live through these times in Central and Eastern Europe. Just as well, the game shines light not only on the realm of high politics, so often the sole subject of games as well as historical writing, but also on the economy, high and everyday culture, and the normal lives of normal people. It’s a two-hour history lesson, and at the same time a lot of fun.
Among the Cold War games, I bestow on it the title The Most Educational.

 

9 thoughts on “1989 (Games about the Cold War, #6)

    1. cliosboardgames Post author

      Thanks for reading! I’ve played Twilight Struggle a lot more often than 1989, but that I suspect that’s chiefly for two reasons: TS was there first, so it’s the default game to scratch that specific itch, and TS’s broader theme has appeal for more of my fellow board gamers.
      Speaking of theme, I’d like to ask you as the expert: How do you think the Polish part of 1989 is done? Is there anything missing/particularly well done/…?
      I’m always curious what people who come from one of the countries depicted in the game have to say about it. (I myself only count for half – I’m from Germany, but from the Western part, so the revolution of 1989 is something my family felt involved with, but still only watched on TV.)

      Like

      Reply
  1. whovian223

    Interesting that the one card example uses “support checks.” Is there maybe (and I know you haven’t played it yet) a little bit of 1960: The Making of a President in here as well as Twilight Struggle?

    Looks like a really great game!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    1. cliosboardgames Post author

      IJason Matthews surely contributed his 1960 experience! Support checks work a bit differently in 1989, though: They are a mix of Twilight Struggle’s coups (die rolling against double stability value) and realignments (bonuses for adjacent controlled spaces).
      And yes, 1989 is a pretty good game. Have not played it as often as I should. But I do hope to get it to the table some time again!
      …and I do hope it makes the P500 for the reprint soon so that more people get to play it!

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply
      1. whovian223

        Maybe I will join the P500. It’s not like I have to worry about paying for it for a while. 😛

        Interesting, and you mentioning them reminds me that I always forget about realignment actions in Twilight Struggle.

        They’re like the forgotten stepchild!

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Twilight Struggle (Games about the Cold War, #8) | Clio's Board Games

  3. Pingback: 1989: Dawn of Freedom from GMT Games – Dude! Take Your Turn!

  4. Pingback: Board Game Geek War Game Top 60: #30-21 | Clio's Board Games

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s